There’s more to life than abortion
From time to time, I used to watch EWTN
news, the Catholic cable channel, at night
before going to bed to catch up on the week’s
headlines in the church.
That stopped in late summer at the height
of the health care debate. I had seen for several
years that EWTN held a major conservative
bias, but the network seemed to provide fair
international coverage, and that is mostly why
I watched.
On the last night I watched EWTN, host
Raymond Arroyo interviewed a man who was
trashing the health care bill as the beginning of
a new welfare state. He then went on to compare
it to President Franklin D. Roosevelt’s New
Deal and how that made the Great Depression
last longer then it was supposed to.
I never caught the man’s name or what he
did for a living. I jumped to change the channel
and have avoided the network ever since.
In all fairness, this wasn’t the first time the
folks at EWTN had resorted to openly attacking
Democrats and their proposals. There was
never a week that had gone by where I didn’t
feel uncomfortable with their coverage.
When browsing their Web site last week,
I came across a Catholic Q-&-A page where
someone had asked why the Democrat’s health
care proposals were evil despite the fact the
government already pays for some abortions.
Their answer represented everything that is
wrong with the network.
“If the current health care proposal were to
become law, which — please God — it will not,
tax payers would literally be paying for abortion
on demand. No matter how you read it,
paying for killing is in there.”
Like health care, most coverage by the network
centers on the abortion topic. On one occasion, I remember watching a segment in
which a priest instructed people on how to get
as many voters to the polls to vote for pro-life
(i.e. Republican) politicians as possible.
Now, the abortion topic is a good thing to
talk about. But when your network spends
practically all of its time focusing on abortion,
you miss other important aspects of health
care, like coverage for disadvantaged people
and illegal immigrants.
Here’s my beef with the “Eternal Word Television
Network.” Aside from being extremely
conservative, it claims to be the de facto voice
of the church in the media, when in fact it is
not. Furthermore, they let their personal biases
affect the way they present the news.
How could it be that a Catholic news channel,
which claims to represent the views of the
faith, is against all things health care when the
Catholic Church itself is in favor of universal
health care for all people?
Of course, the church is not quick to push
the health care issue. While some priests can
talk for days about abortion, rarely (if ever)
do priests give a homily about the joys of universal
health care.
I didn’t even know the church officially
supported universal health care until I sat down to interview a priest back in November, although I just assumed it did because providing
health care to everyone is the morally right
thing to do.
I am often amazed that anyone could
oppose universal health care. When it comes
down to it, conservatives only oppose it
because they don’t want to pay for it. They
claim that it is not the government’s place to
provide for the poor, and instead, the poor
should go to churches and other organizations
when they are in need.
But if most conservatives claim to be good
church-going folk, why would any poor person
be naïve enough to go to a church for help
and expect these people to be generous? After
observing the health care debate for the past
few months, it’s clear conservatives believe it’s
every man for himself.
There is a theory among liberal Catholics
that conservatives fight for the rights of the
unborn, but once you turn 18, they have no
problem sending you off to war and don’t really
care if you can afford health care. In many
cases this is true.
Luckily, EWTN does not speak for the
church. While conservatives have a loud voice
in the church, Catholics as a group are the largest
swing vote in this country, so it is impossible
to label them one thing or the other.
It’s just unfortunate the group that makes
up a quarter of the population in this country
only has one major outlet for news.
Frank Yonkof is a sophomore newspaper journalism
major and columnist for the Daily Kent
Stater. Contact him at [email protected].